By the way, an alternative approach if you just want non-interactive feeds to subscribe to accounts via RSS. Any Mastodon account has an RSS feed which is its normal account profile URL with .rss added to the end.
PeerTube has an RSS subscription option if you click the arrow on an account's "subscribe" button.
Pixelfed supports newsfeeds (but I think they use atom?).
GoToSocial includes RSS support but each user has to manually opt in to activate their feed.
Ah okay! If all you want to do is *show* the old posts, you can open the original page, and there's a link on blank profiles to do this which prompts people to click on it.
But if people can see old posts they may want to interact with them, and wonder why they can't, so that ends up confusing too.
Ideal would be some way to get at least some unpinned posts automatically backfilled the way pinned posts already are.
The developers are aware this is a hindrance, it's just a question of what to do about it.
I've explored some of the possible solutions in the article, such as backfilling where the server automatically fetches some recent posts for profiles you follow (or possibly look at?).
Backfilling is by far the most requested feature on Mastodon's github site, but there are some complications to deal with which are explored in a long thread which I've linked to from the article.
"If you want to do more with that server, then, yes, you may need to have an account there."
Yeah, that's all I meant by "it's more difficult to interact with".
When I've told new people about original pages, they've seen buttons and icons there and often tried to interact with it because they think Mastodon is all one site. Then they get puzzled why they keep being asked to log in again and again on different servers' websites.
I've tried to explain the situation and why this happens in the article. TL:DR: There are good reasons why this happens, because the current alternatives are worse.
This isn't a deliberate choice by the designers, this is a consequence of building a social network that cannot be taken over by people like Musk.
There are features that mitigate this problem though, such as pinning posts, and other features on the way.
Hopefully one upcoming feature on the Mastodon roadmap ("Explicit controls to fetch more data from origin server") should solve a lot of problems. I'm guessing it will let people update a profile by clicking a button on it, in a similar process to original pages but without having to open a separate website.
p.s. As mentioned in the article, there's a very easy way to prevent your own profile *ever* looking blank to anyone!
Pin posts on your profile, and these will always show up no matter what server other people are on. You can pin up to 5 posts on a profile. Here's how to do it:
It can be important for large accounts to pay attention to criticism (as long as it's not actual abuse/prejudice).
Just had a discussion the other day with someone who was pissed off at me. When we chatted a bit further, it turned out the settings I had on my website were preventing their accessibility features working on their browser.
So, if I'd filtered them out based on their initial post, I'd have missed out on really important info and totally valid criticism.
Posting hints and tips about Mastodon and the Fediverse ๐ There are lots of answers to common questions about Mastodon and the Fediverse on my website at https://fedi.tips. If you can't find your answer, @ or DM me and I will try to help! There's no such thing as a silly question!I am a volunteer, you can buy me a coffee at https://ko-fi.com/fedithing or become a patron at https://liberapay.com/FediThingMaintained by @FediThing, banner artwork is by @posiputt