Conversation
Notices
-
"Refuse a treatment or prescription" is notably missing here.
-
There are 3 elements to health freedom:
1. Right to refuse any treatment whatsoever
2. Right to hire anyone you see fit to be your doctor
3. Access to any pharmacological chemical / drug
Point 3 is tricky because people will use it to argue for legalization of drugs, but medical usage should be reasonably easy to differentiate from shooting heroin at a party.
-
@cjd normally that would be included in "get a second opinion", but yes perhaps explicitly stating it would be worthwhile
-
Getting a second opinion doesn't entail that you have any right to refuse treatment whatsoever. It just means you get a second opinion. Whether it agrees with the first may determine care, but that is left to the doctors. This is easily established when you consider the situation in which they agree on treatment. Thus, if the right is not explicitly stated, the right to a second opinion doesn't entail the right to refuse treatment.
-
You have the right to ask questions, but not the right to refuse.
-
@cjd first one encompasses it, no?
-
Generally, they are. I have one good one now, a specialist. My primary is an ass though, and all other doctors to date took a combination of arm twisting and gamesmanship to get them to get along and to do the right thing.
Example, I needed a refill on my albuterol inhaler (I get asthma when it's cold. I don't think it's caused by cold, but some plant or fungus the grows in winter). I request a refill via the online portal. Nurse calls me... "doctor won't refill it without an appointment." I ask to schedule an appointment. She says the earliest he's available is three weeks out. I make the appointment and hang up the phone.
I then get back on the portal, write my doctor, explain how long I've had the script, why I need it — I have asthma right now, and add the magic phrase "please let me know if you will be able to provide timely care."
The script was filled the next morning.
-
Asked for a second opinion once at the VA. They were surprised I wanted to see a DIFFERENT doctor for a 2nd opinion. They actually thought it meant a second opinion from the same doctor. Point is hospitals and doctors are shit.
-
@Humpleupagus @deavmi @Evil_Bender @cjd The problem really is, "general doctors" are just pill pushers, now some specialized doctors do more but surgeons are really who should be called doctor's.