Conversation

Notices

1. Scarlet :02_dance: (scarlet@bae.st)'s status on Friday, 20-Oct-2023 20:39:33 JST Scarlet :02_dance:

   • shortstories
   @shortstories
   You do realize someone being skinny in a picture is not evidence they died from starvation, don't you?
   • shortstories@merovingian.club's status on Friday, 20-Oct-2023 20:39:27 JST shortstories

     in reply to

     • verified neko :verified::verified::verified::makemeneko:

     @roboneko @scarlet

     Zyklon B turns corpses cherry pink or reddish color

     when I learned about the holocaust in government school they taught that the Jewish eye witness who worked at the gas chambers

     said the corpses were blue and that a judge knowing this was the wrong color tried to correct him but he insisted they were blue

     Plenty of Jews went into the gas chambers when they took a water shower because they claimed it was the same building

     Red Cross came in and examined the camps

   • verified neko :verified::verified::verified::makemeneko: (roboneko@bae.st)'s status on Friday, 20-Oct-2023 20:39:28 JST verified neko :verified::verified::verified::makemeneko:

     in reply to

     • shortstories
     @scarlet @shortstories war crimes unit that performs autopsies and holds public viewing hours is pretty amusing tho
     Machismo repeated this.
   • shortstories@merovingian.club's status on Friday, 20-Oct-2023 20:39:29 JST shortstories

     in reply to

     @scarlet

     Never seen alive is not the same as having been seen executed

     A lot of them travelled to different countries and changed their names so they could not find each other

     People have found other people they thought were dead because they moved to a different country

     Who are the credible eye witnesses who saw people poisoned with Zyklon B and the correct bodty colors associated with Cyanide poisoning on the corpses?

     Some survivors testified to having never seen a gas chamber

   • Scarlet :02_dance: (scarlet@bae.st)'s status on Friday, 20-Oct-2023 20:39:29 JST Scarlet :02_dance:

     in reply to

     • shortstories
     @shortstories
     >Some survivors testified to having never seen a gas chamber
     Have you considered for a second that they got to survive BECAUSE they didn't get to see the inside of a gas chamber? What, you think the Nazi's had big glowing Las Vegas signs showing which buildings were the gas chambers? You think they were somehow magically identifiable as gas chambers from the outside?
     
     >Who are the credible eye witnesses who saw people poisoned with Zyklon B
     What, you think Nazis had visiting hours for Jews to see other Jews dying and then examine their corpses too?
     
     >A lot of them traveled to different countries and changed their names so they could not find each other
     Are you suggesting that Jews were frequently being released from Nazi camps?
     
     I noticed you're an antisemite, nothing new around these parts. But your lack of thinking skill is out of this world.
   • Scarlet :02_dance: (scarlet@bae.st)'s status on Friday, 20-Oct-2023 20:39:30 JST Scarlet :02_dance:

     in reply to

     • shortstories
     @shortstories
     Then how about you go back to testimonies and see how many they say died from starvation, and how many were taken by the guards somewhere and never to be seen alive again?
   • shortstories@merovingian.club's status on Friday, 20-Oct-2023 20:39:31 JST shortstories

     in reply to

     @scarlet

     The testimony of some survivors according to my government school education was that they were very mad the allies bombed the train tracks that supplied food to the camps but did not bomb other structures

     It is that alleged textimony that inspired me to write the poll

   • Scarlet :02_dance: (scarlet@bae.st)'s status on Friday, 20-Oct-2023 20:39:32 JST Scarlet :02_dance:

     in reply to

     • shortstories
     @shortstories
     You don't seem to get it. Your poll is meaningless. Don't know what you think you're trying to prove, but you're achieving nothing. Asking the masses what they think, while skewing the results with leading questions and phrases gets you no useful data.
     
     Eugenia Cooney has been a walking skeleton for a decade. People thought, including myself, that she was gonna die years ago, because of footage of her, but she's still alive and kicking.
     You're trying to deceive people into thinking those Jews must have died of starvation, and not executed, because "look at how skinny they were". You're not gonna get some meaningful information about what is really likely to have happened, all you're gonna get is people's biases aggravated by you leading them into thinking people being skinny in pictures is some grand revelation into the cause of their death that people didn't think of before.
     
     The only honest answer to your question is: "I don't know".
     
     If you actually cared about the reality of this matter, you would have gone searching for testimonies of survivors. But you don't care about that.
   • shortstories@merovingian.club's status on Friday, 20-Oct-2023 20:39:33 JST shortstories

     in reply to

     @scarlet

     Correct

     And in the same way a picture of someone falling before they land is not evidence they died of falling they could get shot with a bullet before they landed

     Also would a picture of a fat corpse be evidence they did not die from lack of calories

     If you feel they died of execution and not starving to death even though they are skinny you can vote that way

     I just hope you know they are skinny before you vote even if you vote they died of execution as the cause of death