“All guys want in a girl is for them to be quiet, make food, and have a fat ass” is very odd to me.
I love hearing the girls chirp. Just hanging out and catching up after work, listening to her give me a play by play of her day and all the intricate gossip she’s party to is a good time for me. I like hearing her happy, and nest-y, where you can just feel she’s content to have you back at home with her.
“Be quiet” is silly, it’s more like “don’t be an asshole”, which is an outcropping of living with cantankerous, selfish women with poor impulse control. In a good relationship, you don’t want her being quiet, you want her being happy. And most women get chatty when they’re happy.
The other thing, the food? Yeah, if she’s at home it’s lovely to have her take on food as part of her duties. The fat ass is nice, but it’s also shorthand for “loving”, but that’s a diff. rant.