Conversation

Notices

1. xianc78@gameliberty.club's status on Thursday, 13-Feb-2025 08:26:18 JST xianc78

   Has anyone else noticed that the same people who are criticizing generative AI for "stealing" people's intellectual property are the same people who were claiming that copyright is an outdated concept, years ago?

   You can't have it both ways.

   • xianc78@gameliberty.club's status on Thursday, 13-Feb-2025 08:32:48 JST xianc78

     in reply to

     • :trans_paw:⛧Alex⛧:trans_paw:

     @Alex To be fair, the generative AI could make something that is heavily inspired but not something that would normally be copyright infringing if done by a human.

     My game is using a few AI generated assets (text and backgrounds) and they are too generic to be infringing on anyone's copyright.

   • :trans_paw:⛧Alex⛧:trans_paw: (alex@boymilk.cafe)'s status on Thursday, 13-Feb-2025 08:32:49 JST :trans_paw:⛧Alex⛧:trans_paw:

     in reply to
     I just hate that copyright infringement is only "okay" when the same companies who want you to go to prison or get fined millions of dollars for "stealing" a 40 year old video game do it
   • xianc78@gameliberty.club's status on Thursday, 13-Feb-2025 09:29:56 JST xianc78

     in reply to

     • georgia
     • :trans_paw:⛧Alex⛧:trans_paw:

     @georgia @Alex He co-founded Reddit. He deserved everything that happened to him.

   • georgia (georgia@netzsphaere.xyz)'s status on Thursday, 13-Feb-2025 09:29:58 JST georgia

     in reply to

     • :trans_paw:⛧Alex⛧:trans_paw:
     @Alex @xianc78
     
   • Mr.NutterButter (mr_nutterbutter@gameliberty.club)'s status on Saturday, 15-Feb-2025 18:52:37 JST Mr.NutterButter

     in reply to

     @xianc78 I think you very much can have it both ways.

     These companies are very blatantly stealing stuff to train their AI on.

     With the current copyright system it should get them in trouble or at least given a warning at the very least.

     Everyone knows that the reason they're not is just because they're a large corporation and they can do whatever they want.

     However everyone believed that the current copyright system is bad and should honestly be removed but as of this time when it's still in place these companies should be held accountable.

   • xianc78@gameliberty.club's status on Sunday, 16-Feb-2025 00:35:50 JST xianc78

     in reply to

     • Mr.NutterButter
     • beard :meru_dab:

     @beardalaxy @Mr_NutterButter Except that it isn't just the corporations using AI. Anyone can use it.

   • beard :meru_dab: (beardalaxy@gameliberty.club)'s status on Sunday, 16-Feb-2025 00:35:51 JST beard :meru_dab:

     in reply to

     • Mr.NutterButter

     @Mr_NutterButter @xianc78 yeah, just because you want a system gone, doesn't mean it's okay for someone to abuse the system that's there. That leaves you in the dust as the little guy.

   • Mr.NutterButter (mr_nutterbutter@gameliberty.club)'s status on Sunday, 16-Feb-2025 03:02:37 JST Mr.NutterButter

     in reply to

     @xianc78 most people don't like using it.

     And that still doesn't change the fact of what was previously mentioned.