Conversation
Notices
-
MMS21 :blinkot: (mms21@seal.cafe)'s status on Thursday, 09-May-2024 02:39:20 JST MMS21 :blinkot: It's a haith in Sahih al-Bukhari, not "Sahih Bukhari's Hadith". You're revealing how little you know the more you guys respond. @ChristopherBRobin thought hadith are recorded in the Quran smh 🤣
Why do you believe that Ayesha (RA) was 9? Did she have a calendar? She was misinformed. Saying "I am 9 years old" is not a Islamic ruling, in the sense that it is not something you do, a ruling would be "do not drink alcohol".
We follow authentic hadiths. Saying "it was very warm today" or "I am 9 years old" is not something you can follow as it isn't an order so I have no issues with her being misinformed about her age.
The only thing those hadiths of her age prove is that she said it, not that she was actually 9 years old. Have you got any evidence other than this that she really was 9?
I'm also not calling her a liar because lying implies that she knows her true age, but decided to "lie" about it. She didn't know her age and all the evidence of the prophet refutes this claim of him being a pedophile.
Here's what a hadith scholar has to say about the matter https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=03b97GUacpM